🔍 Read the full analysis: AI’s Economic Payoff: What The Spending Data Can Tell Us on ThorstenMeyerAI.com
Get business pricing on monitors, keyboards and dev gear
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
TL;DR
Apollo economist Torsten Slok says aggregate data show no clear financial payoff from AI outside major technology companies, though the analysis does not isolate AI as the cause. At the same time, Meta has disclosed roughly $825 billion in future commitments, while evidence of gains is more visible in specific workplace and retail experiments than across the wider economy.
Apollo chief economist Torsten Slok says recent company and productivity data show no clear aggregate financial payoff from AI outside the technology sector, as major firms continue committing large sums to computing capacity. His October 24 analysis coincides with disclosures that Meta has roughly $825 billion in future contractual and lease commitments, underscoring the gap between measurable investment and returns that remain difficult to identify across most businesses.
Apollo’s conclusion draws on five charts, including revenue per worker, profit margins, productivity measures and corporate AI spending. Its figures show revenue per worker and margins rising for the Magnificent Seven technology companies—Alphabet, Amazon, Apple, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia and Tesla—while the other 493 S&P 500 companies have remained comparatively flat. Apollo’s chart places the seven at about $780,000 in inflation-adjusted revenue per employee in the third quarter of 2026, compared with roughly $525,000 for the other companies. The figures show a difference between the groups, not that AI alone caused it.
The note also cites San Francisco Federal Reserve measures of productivity, which Apollo says show no signs of AI boosting productivity growth. Ramp, a corporate-card and spending platform, reported that its highest-spending 10% of firms accounted for 99.5% of model-serving and inference spending among its customers. These Ramp figures describe the platform’s more than 85,000 US business customers; they are not a measure of all US firms or of the S&P 500.
Meta’s filings show the scale of investment commitments. Its October 22 quarterly filing lists about $355.73 billion in leases not yet started and $454.52 billion in non-cancelable contractual commitments, largely for cloud capacity, servers and network equipment, plus up to $14.72 billion in contingent cloud purchases. The figures add to about $825 billion, but are not all exclusively for AI. Meta reported $34.91 billion in capital expenditures in the third quarter and narrowed its 2026 spending outlook to $135 billion to $145 billion.
Infographic 01 · The “zero” in numbers
What “zero financial payoff” actually measures.
Apollo’s headline rests on five charts. Here are their numbers, and what they can and cannot prove.
Who pays for AI? Share of spending by the top 10% of firms
Ramp customer data via Apollo · non-AI categories in grey for comparison
Spending is concentrated in every category, not only AI; AI is the most extreme.
What the five charts do and do not show
shown not shown
- Shown: revenue per worker and margins rising for the 7 tech giants, flat for the other 493
- Shown: no AI lift yet in US productivity statistics (San Francisco Fed TFP, output per hour)
- Shown: AI spending sits in few, mostly venture-funded firms (Ramp, 85,000+ US businesses)
- Not shown: that AI caused the gap; rates, tariffs and wages move the same lines
- Not shown: gains inside single functions, which can cancel out in an average
- Not shown: the S&P 493 itself in the Ramp data; those are Ramp’s customers
“The AI story will be decided in the S&P 493, not the Mag 7.”Torsten Slok, Apollo chief economist, 24 Oct 2026 (opinion)
Sources: Apollo Daily Spark (24 Oct 2026) with charts by Bloomberg, Macrobond, SF Fed, BLS and Ramp; Apollo (20 Oct 2026); Ramp AI Index. Values with ≈ are read off Apollo’s charts. Assessment: Thorsten Meyer.
Powered by Thorsten Meyer AI
The Gap Between AI Bills and Returns
The figures matter because companies are making large, long-term commitments to data centers and computing before broad productivity or profit gains are apparent in economy-wide measures. If those investments do not generate enough revenue or cost savings, companies could face pressure on margins, cash flow and their ability to finance additional capacity. The concern extends beyond individual technology firms because AI infrastructure spending depends on suppliers, lenders, energy and cloud services.
But Apollo’s aggregate comparison is not a direct test of AI’s effect. The 493-company average could conceal businesses that are benefiting and others that are not, while changes in rates, wages, tariffs and demand can also affect margins and productivity. Specific experiments suggest gains can occur when AI is fitted to a defined task: the source material cites a customer-support study with 14% more issues resolved per hour, and a 34% gain for novice workers. Retail experiments cited in the material range from no sales lift to an increase of 16.3%, depending on the workflow. Those results do not establish a broad economy-wide return.
Popular right now

Hisense 40-Inch QD4SR Series Hi-QLED Full HD Smart Roku TV

Dyson V9 Motorbar Cordless Vacuum

TCL 55-Inch T7 Series 4K QLED Smart Google TV, 55T7
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What Apollo’s “Zero” Measures
Slok’s October 24 Apollo Daily Spark note, titled “No Signs of AI Payoff Outside the Tech Sector,” was cited by media outlets the following day. The phrase “zero financial payoff” is Slok’s interpretation of aggregate performance trends, not a measured estimate showing AI caused zero returns. The data compare company groups and productivity indicators; they do not isolate AI from other economic forces.
The source material also reports that 83% of nearly 9,000 executives surveyed said AI had not affected their productivity so far, and that the average reported productivity effect was 0.2% a year. Those results are survey findings, not an accounting of realized returns for every company. In another signal of concentrated spending, Ramp data show that 80.4% of the top 1% of AI spenders in its customer base were venture-backed, compared with 13.1% of its median spender. That concentration supports questions about how much demand comes from established corporate budgets versus venture-funded companies.
Meta’s $825 billion figure combines obligations with different timelines and purposes, including leases extending through 2036. It should not be read as a single cash payment due now. Meta also reported third-quarter revenue of $64.60 billion, up 26% year over year, alongside operating cash flow of $32.79 billion and negative free cash flow of $2.12 billion. One quarter’s cash flow does not by itself establish whether the long-term spending will pay off.
““No Signs of AI Payoff Outside the Tech Sector.””
— Torsten Slok, Apollo chief economist, in the October 24 Daily Spark note
How Much AI Is Driving Results
It remains unclear how much of the technology sector’s stronger revenue per worker and margins is attributable to AI rather than to other business lines or economic conditions. Apollo’s comparisons do not establish causation, and flat performance among the other S&P 500 companies does not rule out gains at particular firms or within specific functions.
The disclosed spending totals also do not show how quickly each commitment will turn into cash outlays, how much capacity will be used, or what returns it will generate. Meta’s commitments include non-AI items, and forecasts for other large technology companies are projections rather than contractual obligations. The source material describes financing pressures and rising insurance costs for some AI-related debt, but does not establish a sector-wide funding shortfall. The long-term effect on employment, consumer prices and company profits remains unsettled.
Spending, Earnings and Productivity Ahead
Investors and companies will look for further quarterly disclosures on capital spending, cash flow, AI-related revenue and capacity use. Meta’s stated 2026 capital-spending range provides a near-term benchmark, while its filings give a longer view of leases and contracts. Results over coming quarters may show whether infrastructure commitments are matched by paying demand and measurable operating improvements.
Productivity data and company-level studies will also need time to show whether gains spread beyond technology suppliers and selected workplace tasks. Until those measures provide a clearer picture, Apollo’s analysis is best read as a warning that broad returns are not yet visible in the cited aggregate indicators, not as proof that AI produces no value. The central question is whether measurable benefits grow fast enough to justify continuing investment and financing costs.
Key Questions
What did Apollo mean by saying AI has delivered “zero” payoff outside tech?
Apollo’s Torsten Slok used the phrase to describe aggregate trends: revenue per worker and margins rose for seven large technology companies but were comparatively flat for the other 493 S&P 500 firms. The data do not measure AI’s causal effect or prove that every non-tech company has had zero returns.
What is included in Meta’s roughly $825 billion in commitments?
The total combines about $355.73 billion in leases not yet started, $454.52 billion in non-cancelable contractual commitments and up to $14.72 billion in contingent cloud purchases. The commitments cover data centers and infrastructure such as cloud capacity, servers and network equipment, and are not all exclusively for AI or immediately payable.
Are companies seeing any measurable AI gains?
The source material cites task-specific results, including a customer-support study reporting 14% more issues resolved per hour, with a 34% gain for novice workers. Retail experiments cited there range from no sales increase to a 16.3% increase, depending on the workflow. Those findings do not establish broad gains across the economy.
Does the evidence show that AI investment is unprofitable?
No. Apollo’s charts indicate that broad gains are difficult to see in the measures it examined, but they do not isolate AI’s effects or forecast future returns. Company-level benefits, costs and investment outcomes remain uneven and developing.
Source: ThorstenMeyerAI.com
