TL;DR
RMI’s recent hydrogen research recognizes cost and demand barriers, including battery trucks’ cost advantage and lower European renewable-hydrogen demand than earlier targets implied. A CleanTechnica analysis argues that some RMI recommendations still call for public support to develop hydrogen markets without showing that hydrogen outperforms alternatives.
RMI’s hydrogen research increasingly recognizes cost and demand constraints, but some of its recommendations still call for public support for hydrogen vehicles, refuelling networks and new fuel markets, according to a CleanTechnica analysis. The gap matters because governments, investors and industrial companies use RMI research to inform decisions about public spending and infrastructure.
Get business pricing on monitors, keyboards and dev gear
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
The analysis points to RMI’s February 2026 report on hydrogen trucking in India. In its baseline comparisons, fuel-cell trucks do not reach ownership-cost parity with battery-electric trucks through 2040, including for long-haul use. A separate, more favourable hydrogen-price sensitivity brings fuel-cell trucks closer to parity, but the analysis says that scenario should not be confused with the baseline finding. Despite the baseline result, RMI recommends vehicle subsidies, refuelling-station support, production incentives and tax relief.
RMI’s 2025 U.S. hydrogen report similarly says battery trucks are more market-ready and have lower total cost of ownership, particularly in the near term, while recommending hydrogen distribution and refuelling infrastructure along freight corridors. The CleanTechnica analysis also cites ownership-cost work from NACFE’s Run on Less program, which projects batteries becoming the lowest-cost option across its modelled duty cycles by 2035 without incentives. It says hydrogen remains the costliest option in nearly all of those cases.
The assessment contrasts those recommendations with RMI research it views as more disciplined about comparing services. A 2026 steel analysis distinguishes hydrogen used to reduce iron ore from hydrogen used to provide process heat. For an illustrative plant, it estimates electric heating would require about 850 GWh of electricity a year, compared with 1,300 GWh to produce the additional hydrogen needed for heating. The source also describes RMI’s Green Ammonia Buyers Alliance as addressing an existing industrial need: replacing fossil-derived hydrogen in ammonia production with lower-emissions ammonia.
RMI’s research improves investment advice still faces scrutiny
RMI’s research increasingly recognizes cost and demand barriers, while some recommendations continue to support hydrogen markets. The debate matters for public spending and long-lived infrastructure.
What trucking comparisons show
The analysis says baseline costs and recommendations do not always point in the same direction.
- Fuel-cell trucks do not reach ownership-cost parity with battery trucks through 2040.
- Battery trucks are described as more market-ready and lower cost in the near term.
- Vehicle subsidies and production incentives.
- Support for refuelling stations and freight-corridor infrastructure.
Compare the service
The analysis argues that policy should compare ways to deliver the needed product or service.
Move goods
Compare hydrogen trucks with battery-electric alternatives on consistent cost and emissions assumptions.
Make iron and steel
Distinguish hydrogen used to reduce iron ore from hydrogen used for process heat.
Supply fertiliser
Replacing fossil-derived hydrogen in ammonia production addresses an existing industrial need.
Evidence before investment
Readers need fuller data to judge how assumptions affect the comparisons.
- Separate baseline results from more favourable sensitivities.
- Compare costs, emissions, timing and infrastructure across feasible alternatives.
- Make energy-security or resilience benefits explicit alongside public expense.
Public Money and Hydrogen Markets
The disagreement is about more than forecasts. Subsidies, production incentives and refuelling infrastructure can direct public funds and private investment toward one technology and create long-lived assets. If a report finds that batteries are cheaper for a transport use case, policymakers need a clear reason to support a hydrogen alternative rather than treating market growth as a goal in itself.
For industry, the relevant requirement is often a product or service, not hydrogen as such. Fertiliser producers need ammonia; steelmakers need iron and steel that meet quality and emissions requirements; factories need process heat. Comparing ways to deliver those outputs can reveal options such as direct electrification or importing lower-emissions products. The CleanTechnica analysis argues that policy should also state and value any separate benefits of maintaining domestic production, such as security or resilience, rather than leaving those costs implicit.
The implications extend to energy planning. Building a market for ammonia as a fuel, for example, requires comparing it with renewable electricity, storage and other ways to provide flexibility. The source says RMI’s cited China report acknowledges that green ammonia and methanol cost two to three times as much as conventional production and that demand development trails supply ambitions, while still discussing expanded energy-carrier uses. It argues the case for those uses has not been demonstrated by the comparisons presented.
Popular right now

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones Gen 1, Lunar Blue

Apple AirPods Pro 3 Wireless Earbuds

De'Longhi Magnifica Evo Automatic Espresso Machine with Milk Frother, Silver
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
RMI’s Changing Hydrogen Assessments
The CleanTechnica author says they have questioned the gap between RMI’s analysis and recommendations since January 2024. The piece credits RMI with improving its treatment of competing technologies and demand. It cites the group’s March 2025 European recalibration, which put expected mandate-driven renewable-hydrogen demand in 2030 at 2.2 million to 2.8 million tons, below the EU’s original 20-million-ton supply-and-import ambition.
That European analysis identified €13.9 billion in public support under existing mandates and an additional €31.7 billion for an accelerated scenario. The CleanTechnica author says the combined €45.6 billion should be assessed against alternatives that could provide the same low-carbon products and services. The source further cites a November 2026 assessment modelling European ammonia costs at about €1,222 per ton for domestic production using on-site green hydrogen and €745 to €755 per ton for qualifying imports. Those figures are model outputs, not supplier bids.
These examples do not establish that hydrogen has no role. The source distinguishes hydrogen used as a chemical feedstock or to reduce iron ore from uses where electricity may provide the same service more efficiently. Its central criticism is that the same service-by-service comparison should guide recommendations across sectors.
Where the Cost Comparisons Fall Short
The source does not provide full underlying datasets, methodological details or complete report excerpts for every comparison it discusses. The Indian trucking result depends on the report’s assumptions, including the baseline hydrogen price; the more favourable sensitivity is not quantified in the supplied material. Readers cannot assess from this source alone how changes in fuel prices, vehicle costs, infrastructure use or policy would affect the results.
The cited European ammonia figures are modelled estimates, not market offers, and the source does not provide enough detail to independently evaluate the assumptions behind them. It also does not include a response from RMI addressing the criticism that its recommendations do not follow consistently from its findings. The source’s references to RMI’s reports are editorial summaries, not full reproductions of their conclusions.
It remains unclear which hydrogen uses could become competitive under changed costs or conditions, and how RMI weighs potential energy-security or industrial-resilience benefits against public expense. The evidence presented supports scrutiny of specific proposals; it does not establish that every hydrogen application is uneconomic.
Evidence Needed for Policy Choices
The next step for governments and investors is to test proposed hydrogen spending against the service it is meant to provide: freight movement, process heat, steel production, ammonia supply or grid flexibility. That means comparing hydrogen with batteries, direct electrification, storage, imports and other feasible routes using consistent assumptions on cost, emissions, timing and infrastructure.
For RMI, the analysis argues that recommendations should state when they are based on a baseline versus a sensitivity, identify the cases where hydrogen has a demonstrated advantage, and explain the public rationale for supporting uses that remain more expensive. Any claimed benefits for domestic capacity should be set out alongside the cost of subsidies and infrastructure.
The reports and recommendations discussed here are already public, but the source identifies no scheduled RMI response or policy decision. Further clarity will depend on fuller report data, responses to the criticism and updated cost comparisons as technologies and markets change.
Key Questions
What is the central criticism of RMI?
The CleanTechnica analysis says RMI’s findings have become more realistic about hydrogen’s costs and demand, but some recommendations still support subsidies and infrastructure to develop markets where the analysis identifies competing options.
What did RMI’s India trucking report find?
In the report’s baseline comparison, fuel-cell trucks do not reach ownership-cost parity with battery-electric trucks through 2040, including in the long-haul case. A more favourable hydrogen-price sensitivity brings them closer to parity, according to the source.
How much lower was RMI’s European 2030 hydrogen-demand estimate?
RMI’s March 2025 recalibration put expected mandate-driven renewable-hydrogen demand at 2.2 million to 2.8 million tons in 2030, compared with the EU’s original 20-million-ton supply-and-import ambition. These figures refer to different measures and should not be treated as a direct forecast-to-target comparison without that context.
Does the analysis say hydrogen has no useful role?
No. It distinguishes uses such as hydrogen for iron-ore reduction or as an input to ammonia production from applications where batteries or direct electricity may serve the same function. Its argument is that each proposed use should be compared with alternatives.
What remains unresolved?
The supplied material does not provide complete methodologies and datasets for independently checking every comparison, and it includes no RMI response to the criticism. The competitiveness of particular hydrogen uses under different prices, technologies or security priorities also remains open.
Source: CleanTechnica
